Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Review of Starry Night: A Christmas Novel

Starry Night: A Christmas Novel
frazerc avatar reviewed on + 672 more book reviews


First off, I love Debbie Macombers Christmas novels and re-read many of them seasonally. This one wont be one of those that I re-read however. Dont get me wrong it was a good read-once but lacked the ahhh element that brings me back again and again.



That said, this is a good read with interesting characters and a relationship-driven plot. The heroine is Carrie Slayton, a reporter desperate to escape the doldrums of the society pages of her Chicago newspaper. To this end she approaches her editor who agrees to move her to real reporting if she successfully gets an interview with the reclusive author of the hot best-seller Alone. The hero is said author, Finn Dalton, who wrote the book to inspire others to step out their doors and really see nature, not just pass through it. He never expected it to be an overwhelming success and he especially never expected to be hounded by reporters, newscasters, and talk show gurus.



Carrie manages to locate Finns mother and she actually talks to her rather than slamming the door in her face. Although they are estranged and have been since Finn was a child she does share some clues with her and gives Carrie Finns fathers wedding ring to return to Finn. Using the clues Carrie travels to Alaska and using the ring she manages to talk one of Finns friends into flying her to his cabin. They arrive in the teeth of a storm so he drops her off and points in the direction of the cabin.



By now she realizes that winter in Chicago had not prepared her for winter in the high north but her options are limited so she trudges off towards the cabin. Theres ice and snow and wind and suddenly a wolf and Finn who collects her from where she had fallen like she was a dropped blanket and carries her off to his cabin. The wolf turns out to be Finns dog and neither of them is very happy to see her.



Finn is a man with issues. Big ones. Issues like abandonment and betrayal and trust especially related to women. The last thing Finn wants is some reporter tracking him down to write an article about him. During the storm-enforced captivity they begin to talk and slowly become if not friends than at least not enemies. When the storm finally clears he takes her outside and they watch the aurora-streaked brilliance of the starry night and she finally begins to understand the man and why he would want to be in this place and in this time. And why she will leave at least a little part of her heart behind when she leaves.



Carrie has her article but will she print it? Finn has asked her not to but its the chance for the break shes been looking for. What to do



Finn is finding being alone synonymous with lonely. He and Carrie begin a long distance relationship via phones, and emails and posts. Things are poignant but then he comes for a visit Pick an emotion and shes there: deliriously happy, frightened, angry when a friend figures out who he is and suggests hes just doing it to manipulate her into not publishing the article and calling her a fool for refusing to do so. Complications abound Finn goes back to Alaska. She goes home for the holidays. Both of them are miserable. Since this is a Debbie Macomber novel you know its going to work out in the end but it takes a painfully long time.